Are Smart Locks Better Than Traditional Locks?

In today’s connected world, smart locks are becoming increasingly popular in American homes. But are they truly better than traditional deadbolts and keyed locks? This comprehensive guide examines both options across security, convenience, cost, and reliability to help you decide which is right for your home.

Understanding the Basics: Smart Locks vs. Traditional Locks

What Are Traditional Locks?

Traditional locks have been securing homes for centuries and include:

Deadbolts (single/double/triple cylinder)
Knob locks (common but less secure)
Mortise locks (higher security commercial-grade)
Key-in-knob locks (basic residential security)

These mechanical locks operate purely through physical keys and manual turning mechanisms.

What Are Smart Locks?

Smart locks are electronic locking systems that offer keyless entry through:

Keypads (PIN code entry)
Smartphone apps (Bluetooth/Wi-Fi connectivity)
Biometrics (fingerprint/facial recognition)
Voice control (Alexa/Google Assistant integration)
Remote access (lock/unlock from anywhere)

Security Showdown: Which Is More Secure?

Traditional Lock Security

Pros:
No digital vulnerabilities (can’t be hacked remotely)
Proven technology with standardized security ratings (ANSI Grade 1-3)
No power/battery dependence

Cons:
Vulnerable to lock picking/bumping (YouTube has made this alarmingly easy)
Physical keys can be copied/lost/stolen
No activity monitoring (no way to know who entered or when)

Smart Lock Security

Pros:
Advanced encryption (most use 128-bit or 256-bit AES)
No physical keys to lose/duplicate
Activity logs track all entries/exits
Temporary access codes for guests/service people
Tamper alerts and auto-locking features

Cons:
Potential hacking vulnerabilities (though rare with proper security)
Dependent on power/batteries
Some models have weaker physical construction than high-end deadbolts

Security Verdict: While traditional locks are vulnerable to physical attacks, smart locks introduce digital risks. High-quality smart locks (like those with ANSI Grade 1 certification) generally offer superior security when properly configured.

Convenience Comparison

Traditional Lock Convenience

Pros:
Always works (no tech failures)
Universally understood operation
No batteries to replace

Cons:
Key management is inconvenient (losing keys is common)
No remote access capability
Rekeying is required when keys are lost/stolen

Smart Lock Convenience

Pros:
Keyless entry (never get locked out)
Remote access via smartphone
Temporary access for guests/deliveries
Integration with smart home systems
Auto-locking features prevent unlocked doors

Cons:
Learning curve for some users
Potential app/connectivity issues
Battery changes required (typically every 6-12 months)

Convenience Verdict: Smart locks win overwhelmingly for modern lifestyles, eliminating key hassles and offering remote management capabilities traditional locks can’t match.

Cost Analysis

Traditional Lock Costs

Basic deadbolt: $20 -$ 50
High-security deadbolt: $50 -$ 150
Professional installation: $75 -$ 150
Rekeying: $50 -$ 100 per occurrence

Smart Lock Costs

Basic smart lock: $100 -$ 200
Premium smart lock: $200 -$ 400
Installation: $0 -$ 150 (many are DIY-friendly)
No rekeying costs (digital credentials can be revoked)

Cost Verdict: While smart locks have higher upfront costs, they eliminate recurring rekeying expenses and provide value through enhanced features.

Reliability Factors

Traditional Lock Reliability

Always operational (no tech failures)
Works during power outages
No software updates needed

Smart Lock Reliability

Most include physical key backup
Battery life typically 6-12 months
Many work locally (Bluetooth) without internet
Potential connectivity issues
Firmware updates occasionally required

Reliability Verdict: Traditional locks are simpler and more consistently reliable, but quality smart locks with backup options are nearly as dependable for daily use.

Special Considerations for American Homeowners

Climate Factors

Extreme cold can affect smart lock batteries
Humidity/salt air may impact electronic components
Traditional locks generally withstand all weather conditions better

Home Insurance Impacts

Some insurers offer discounts for smart locks (check with your provider)
High-security traditional locks may also qualify for discounts

Rental Property Needs

Smart locks are ideal for Airbnb/rental properties
Traditional locks may suffice for long-term rentals

Who Should Choose Which Option?

Choose Traditional Locks If You:

Prefer simple, time-tested technology
Live in areas with poor internet connectivity
Want the absolute lowest maintenance option
Have concerns about digital security

Choose Smart Locks If You:

Want keyless convenience
Frequently need to grant temporary access
Value remote monitoring/control
Have other smart home devices
Want enhanced security features

Best of Both Worlds: Hybrid Solutions

Many homeowners opt for a combination:

Primary entry: High-security smart lock
Secondary doors: Traditional deadbolts
Backup: Physical key hidden in secure location

This approach provides smart convenience while maintaining traditional reliability where needed.

Final Verdict: Which Is Better?

For most modern American households, smart locks offer significant advantages in convenience and functionality that outweigh their slightly higher cost and minimal reliability concerns. However, traditional locks remain a perfectly valid choice for those who prioritize simplicity and absolute reliability over high-tech features.

The best choice depends on your:

Budget
Technical comfort level
Security needs
Lifestyle requirements

As smart lock technology continues improving and prices decrease, they’re becoming the clear future of home security. But there’s still a strong case for traditional locks in certain situations.

What’s your preference? Have you made the switch to smart locks?

Contact us

How can we help you

Related Blog

Blog